Enneagram Social Four: The Comparative Four
Enneagram Fours are known for their emotional depth, individuality, and longing for authenticity. At their core, Fours want to be seen for who they truly are, while fearing they are flawed or missing something essential. Each subtype of Four expresses this tension differently, depending on which instinct leads.
The Social Four (Social 4) has been nicknamed “Shame,” a term used by Enneagram teacher Beatrice Chestnut in The Complete Enneagram, expanding on psychiatrist Claudio Naranjo’s early work with subtypes. “Shame” reflects the Social 4’s tendency to compare themselves to others and feel they come up short, leading to visible emotional suffering and longing.
For accessibility, I’ll also call this subtype “The Comparative Four.” This phrase highlights how Social 4s instinctively measure themselves against others, often amplifying feelings of inadequacy while also fueling their creative drive.
In this post, we’ll explore the defining traits of the Social Four, how they show up in relationships and work, how they differ from the other Four subtypes, and what growth looks like for them.
Please note - this post contains affiliate links. If you click and make a purchase, I may earn a small commission at no extra cost to you.
The Social Four at a Glance
At their core, Fours long to be authentic and understood. They fear they are fundamentally flawed or lacking.
The passion of Type Four is envy—a painful sense that others have something they lack.
When the Social instinct leads, this envy becomes outwardly visible. Social 4s often feel a sharp contrast between themselves and others, leading to shame, comparison, and longing.
🔑 Key themes for Social 4s include:
Comparison
They measure themselves against others, often unfavorably.Visible suffering
They express pain outwardly, sometimes dramatically.Longing for recognition
They crave validation and acknowledgment of their uniqueness.Creativity through pain
Their suffering often fuels artistic or expressive work.
In short: Social 4s embody the most visibly emotional and comparative version of the Four.
Strengths and Challenges of Social 4s
The Comparative Individualist brings profound emotional depth but also struggles with self-esteem.
💪 Strengths
Expressive
They communicate emotions with honesty and artistry.Empathetic
Their sensitivity allows them to understand others’ suffering.Creative
They often channel their emotions into meaningful art or expression.Authentic
They refuse to hide their pain, modeling raw honesty.
⚠️ Challenges
Chronic comparison
They may constantly feel “less than” others.Visible suffering
Their emotional displays can overwhelm or alienate others.Dependence on validation
They may look to others to confirm their worth.Self-absorption
Their focus on their own pain can make it hard to connect outward.
Social 4s often appear deeply authentic, but inside they may feel consumed by envy and shame.
Social 4s in Relationships and Work
How does this subtype show up in daily life? Let’s look at relationships and work together, since the themes overlap.
❤️ In Relationships
Social 4s bring emotional depth, honesty, and intensity to their relationships. They value authenticity and want partners who can sit with complexity and depth.
But their tendency toward comparison and visible suffering can strain intimacy. They may idealize or devalue their partner, or feel perpetually dissatisfied, fearing that they are not good enough.
For growth, Social 4s need to practice grounding in self-worth rather than looking outward for validation.
💼 At Work
In professional life, Social 4s often shine in creative or expressive fields where emotional authenticity is valued. They bring sensitivity and originality to their work.
However, they may struggle in competitive environments, as comparison triggers envy and shame. They may also focus more on emotional expression than practical achievement.
Their growth edge at work is to balance creativity with structure and to anchor their worth beyond recognition.
How Social 4s Differ from Other Type Four Subtypes
Each Four subtype channels envy and longing differently:
Social 4 vs. Self-Preservation 4:
Self-Preservation 4s endure hardship with quiet resilience.
Social 4s express their suffering outwardly, often visibly.
Self-Preservation 4s appear stoic; Social 4s appear emotionally raw.
Social 4 vs. Sexual 4:
Social 4s compare themselves to others and display longing.
Sexual 4s channel envy into intensity, competition, and emotional passion.
Social 4s show vulnerability; Sexual 4s show fire.
This helps explain why some Fours appear quiet and enduring, while others seem visibly emotional or fiercely competitive.
The Growth Path for Social 4s
For the Social Four, growth means shifting from comparison and shame to grounded self-acceptance.
Key growth practices include:
Release comparison:
Notice when envy is triggered and redirect attention inward.Practice gratitude:
Focus on what is present rather than what is missing.Anchor worth internally:
Cultivate self-acceptance independent of others’ validation.Balance expression with action:
Pair emotional honesty with constructive steps forward.
When Social 4s move beyond comparison, they discover that their authenticity is already valuable—and that their depth can inspire rather than isolate.
Final Thoughts
The Social Four—Shame, or the Comparative Four—is expressive, creative, and emotionally authentic. They bring depth and empathy, but often struggle with comparison and visible suffering. Their growth lies in embracing self-acceptance, balancing expression with grounded action, and remembering that their worth is not defined by others.
If you identify with this subtype, you might ask yourself:
“Am I defining myself by what I lack—or by the value I already bring?”
Want to explore all 27 Enneagram subtypes and see how they shape behavior, relationships, and growth?
👉 Download my free Enneagram Subtypes Guide here.
